Same Stem with Clashing Branches (天比地沖)
Learn the Tyean convention for two pillars with matching stems and clashing branches, including repetition, competition, timing, and school disclosure.
Editorially reviewed: Jul 22, 2026 · Reviewed by Tyean · Editorial Methodology
Learn the Tyean convention for two pillars with matching stems and clashing branches, including repetition, competition, timing, and school disclosure.
Overview
Tyean uses 天比地沖 for two compared pillars whose Heavenly Stems are identical while their Earthly Branches form a Six-Clash pair. Some schools broaden 天比 to same-phase peer stems, so the convention must be stated. Repeated upper identity and lower opposition are assessed separately and do not prove conflict between people.
At a glance
Declare what counts as 天比
Under the Tyean rule, the two compared stems must be identical. If a lineage includes same-phase peer stems, disclose that broader convention before comparing results.
Keep upper repetition and lower clash distinct
Record the repeated stem’s roots, roles, and pillar positions. Then confirm the lower Six-Clash pair and evaluate its branch force independently.
Track temporary repetition precisely
A timing pillar may repeat a natal stem while clashing that pillar’s branch. The compound contact belongs to the active period and can change when annual or monthly layers join.
Do not invent interpersonal conflict
天比地沖 cannot alone prove rivalry, sibling conflict, duplicate opportunities, accident, relocation, or loss. Use it as a pillar-topology description and verify any life interpretation separately.
Related definitions
Ten Heavenly Stems in Bazi
Use the complete ten-stem table to check Chinese character, pinyin, order, Five Phase, Yin-Yang polarity, Day Master role, roots, and reading limits.
Twelve Earthly Branches in Bazi
Use the complete 12 Earthly Branches table for character, pinyin, animal, element, polarity, solar month, double-hour, hidden stems, and Bazi chart role.
Five Elements in Bazi (Wu Xing): Meanings, Cycles and Chart Method
Learn the Five Elements in Bazi—Wood, Fire, Earth, Metal and Water—their cycles, chart carriers, strength checks and a worked reading method.
Related Insights
How to Read Combinations, Clashes, Punishments, and Harms in Bazi
Learn how to read combinations, clashes, punishments, and harms as part of a relationship network instead of isolated labels.
How to Read He Chong Xing Hai in Bazi: Why Many Live in Structures That Pull and Tangle More Easily
How do you read He Chong Xing Hai in Bazi? Learn why combinations, clashes, punishments, and harms are not simple good-or-bad labels, but structural interaction patterns that shape relationship tension, marriage movement, career friction, and long-term life drag.
Use with Tyean
Free Bazi Chart
Generate the Four Pillars and inspect stems, branches, hidden stems, and element distribution.
Sources and editorial basis
同体系词条
本页内容由太乙数衍整理汇编,结合传统经典与 AI 深度解析。以上内容仅作学习参考。